November 7th, 2008 by Michael Jezierski

Teacher Belittles Student For Supporting McCain

This happened in North Carolina. The subtitles are in Scandanavian but the audio is in English.

YouTube Preview Image

19 Responses to “Teacher Belittles Student For Supporting McCain”

  1. Should the link not open, here is the text of the story:

    A Cumberland County school teacher is defending her comments to a fifth-grade pupil who expressed support for John McCain in her class last spring.

    The exchange at Mary McArthur Elementary School was captured by a Swedish television documentary crew, and the video is making the rounds on the Internet including YouTube.

    In the video, which reportedly aired in Scandinavia earlier this week, teacher Diatha D. Harris calls the Iraq War “senseless” and tells one student whose father is a soldier that McCain would keep troops there for 100 years.

    The classroom discussion begins with Harris asking the class who they support for president. When two students say McCain, she responds with “Oh Lord” and “Oh Jesus.”

    She asks them why they are you pulling for McCain or Obama. One student says she supports Obama because “he is making good changes” like “not having a fight between Iraq, and having soldiers killed.”

    “So in other words,” Harris says, “Barack is going to end that war in Iraq.”

    One girls says she supports McCain. When asked why, she tells her teacher “I think it’s because of my parents are going for him, too.’’

    Harris points out that the girl’s father is in the military, then says to the class that Iraq is a “senseless war.”

    “And by the way,” Harris tells the girl, “the person that you’re picking for president said that our troops could stay in Iraq for another hundred years if they need to. So that means that your daddy could stay in the military for another hundred years.”

    The girl appears to be embarrassed and doesn’t respond.

    Harris said three children in the class had parents in the military.

    In an interview late Thursday, Harris, 53, said somebody edited the video to make it appear she was an Obama partisan imposing her views on a child. In fact, Harris said, she made gestures after pupils voiced support for Obama.

    “It has been doctored,” Harris said. “They didn’t show anything about Obama.”

    In another sequence on the video, however, Harris sports an Obama button during a pep rally at the school.

    Wanda McPhaul, a spokeswoman for Cumberland schools, said county officials were shocked when they were alerted to the video.

    But McPhaul said Superintendent Bill Harrison, who will post his own videotaped statement on the matter on YouTube later today, is prohibited by state law from revealing what might happen to Harris.

    Earlier this week, reports about the video on the Internet said Harris was a teacher in Asheville. She used to be a teacher in western North Carolina, but moved to Fayetteville within the past couple years.

    Staff writer Francis X. Gilpin can be reached at gilpinf@fayobserver.com or 323-4848, ext. 372

  2. dispicable

  3. I agree that it is bad. I think the teacher did as well as she knew to do. But the line about McCain keeping the girl’s Daddy in Iraq for 100 years was not only ignorant/wrong, but also cruel.

    I think this is a fairly good argument for teaching the 3 R’s and staying away from “Current Events”.

  4. This is an act of bullying someone little in order to think and act as you like or risk fearing my wrath

    How did the school even allow this woman to wear a pin for Obama in class?

  5. Why is this teacher not on suspension? Even when my 8th grader went to her Social Studies teacher after class to speak about politics, the teacher politely told her it was not ok for the teachers to discuss it with the children.

  6. This young lady, who bravely answered her teacher’s questions, will hopefully receive an apology from the school. Had a teacher spoken to me in that way, my mother would have had a few choice words of her own. The interesting part will be how much it costs to transfer this disgrace to another district.

  7. Why did other teachers or administrators in the bldg not tell someone she was wearing an Obama pin in the classroom?

  8. Can’t say I’m not surprised. What I am surprised about is how stupid this teacher is about doing this on a video. She is obviously a low IQ teacher. However, that’s also not much of a surprise considering the crappy education our schools provide for the nation’s children. Amazing they have all this and a separate interview of this teacher lieing her fat ass about what she just did on the video complete with an Obama supporter button on her super extra large t-shirt. I would support firing the moron and giving her job to anyone recently laid off regardless of education. It would be an improvement.

  9. Guys, the teacher was wrong. She has apologized to the child and the parents, and they support her. This was a 3 minute clip of a 7 hour day in that class, so none of us have the full picture here. There are issues with our education system, let’s talk about that, but let us not turn this into a witch-hunt. It is beneath us. We Conservatives have 4-8 years to go back and regroup. And we need to.

  10. I don’t think the teacher was lying in the interview. She believed that what she said was true. She is simply deluded (like so many on Tuesday). Let’s not be like the Dems who claim that if we are incorrect about something that we are lying. It cheapens the term. I still contend that it is an inappropriate topic for that particular age.

    But persis, our timeframe cannot be 4 or 8 years. The time frame is 2 years. We cannot allow 4 years of Obama running unfettered. We need to be aiming to take back the House in 2010.

  11. This is typical. It happens to my children everyday. Democrats are intolerant of Republican views, and black children learn from their parents to be racist against whites. My white/hispanic daughter comes home crying because her black friend calls her racist because we voted for McCain. I don’t understand why racism is allowed when it’s against whites.?

  12. This woman is a hypocrite, bigot, and a liar. I think her school district would be derelict in their duty if they did not investigate this further. Apology be damed! If this was a white republican talking to a black student, it would be on every major news network with a mob rule approach to getting this teacher summarily fired. I am absolutely outraged. What this woman did borders on child abuse. It does not look like those kids learned that much in that classroom on that particular day. What on God’s green earth did she actually teach them that day! Is this really the example of the kind of person and character that is teaching our children? If it is, then I am disgusted. It is hard enough to be belittled in front of your friends at that age, but to play on a child’s fears by promoting your own political agenda? I just can’t believe what I have seen. When are educators (if that’s what they are called) going to learn that it is their job to teach our kids HOW to think, not WHAT to think.

  13. Wow, she had a political debate with children. Kids are too young to be asked who they support for President. It’s wildly inappropriate. And to browbeat a child for something they know nothing about is the height of bullying. There are reasons why kids are not allowed to vote.

  14. Coleman Curtis Says:
    November 10th, 2008 at 8:09 pm

    Typical and deplorable! I don’t care who the teacher supports in an election. The nuances of national interests, national security and reasons for going to war are beyond the grade level of these students and way beyond the capabilities of the teacher.

    Irrespective of the distorting of a presidential candidate’s position on Iraq, the humiliation and abuse of children with family members in the military is inexcuseable and the teacher should be disciplined by the school board if not dismissed.

  15. This sort of thing is just disgusting to me. My mother is a teacher and if she expressed her religious beliefs (Protestant Christian) or political ones (conservative republican) to high school students who asked her about them she’d get in trouble.

    Here we have a woman bullying young elementary school children who have different political beliefs from her. How does someone with sort of radical mindset (not her politics, but her use of her position as teacher to impose them) become a teacher?

  16. THIS TEACHER WAS DEFININATELY WRONG. SOUNDS LIKE SHE LEARNED THIS IN CHURCH AS THAT IS ABOUT ALL HALF OF THE PEOPLE GO TO CHURCH FOR IS HOW TO CHEAT THE GOVERNMENT EVERYONE HAS AN OPINION BUT ONE MUST BE VERY CAREFUL WHAT IS SAID TO THE LITTLE ONES THEY HAVE EARS MEMMORIES AND FEELINGS. THAT LADY IS NOT A TEACHER SHE IS LIVING IN THE TIMES OF HER GREART GREAT GRAND PARENTS SHE SHOULD BE DISMISSED,,

  17. she’s not a very good cheerleader either…

  18. It’s almost a tradition for teachers to belittle students for their beliefs. Coaches are the worst, but other teachers try to match them.

    I think teachers should challenge students’ beliefs - not trying to bully them into changing their beliefs, but trying to get students to think.

    Kids have a tendency to adopt what someone else says as their own belief, without really examining it. That’s dangerous. If you get them to think, you’re turning them from docile sheep into goats.

    It’s a lot easier to manage a school full of sheep than a school full of goats, but that’s the job of a school. Admiral Grace Hopper pointed out that a ship is safe in harbor - but that’s not what a ship is for.

    Our society is safe and strong to the degree that our citizens are armed - and the arms they need most are not made of blue steel. They need to be armed with functional gray matter. A citizen that thinks is dangerous to any who attempt to destroy this country.

  19. Mister English Says:
    November 18th, 2008 at 3:30 pm

    The worse have gone into education while picking up a major in college. I could never have a small conservation with some of the teachers I’ve encountered at a coffeeshop. They’re either ignorant or worse culturally inferior. All the white parents should take their kids out that school. As for the teacher, can she pass a written test–if given an article to read, would she be able to develop an essay? The answer is simple. What a shame. North Carolina is down the drain.

Leave a Reply

*
To prove that you're not a bot, enter this code
Anti-Spam Image