The Final Part of “fishy” truths about HR3200:
Truth #9: Taxes on Health Benefits
What the bill does: Section 1802(b) of the bill includes provisions that would finance a new Comparative Effectiveness Research Trust Fund. The bottom of page 835 of the bill makes clear the funding source: “CHAPTER 34—TAXES ON CERTAIN INSURANCE POLICIES.”
What this means for Americans: The American people will see their health insurance taxed for the first time ever, breaking two central campaign promises made by then-Senator Obama—not to raise taxes for individuals with incomes under $250,000, and not to tax individuals’ health benefits. The language also breaks a promise by Speaker Pelosi that, “We will not be taxing [health] benefits in any bill that passes the House.”
This also breaks a campaign promise of Obama on taxing health benefits. But Obama also said something about lobbyists that went out the window no sooner than the moving van turned off Pennsylvania Ave back in January, so I digress.
Truth #10: Taxpayer-Funded Research Could Deny Patients Needed Health Care
What the bill does: Section 1401 of the bill establishes a new multi-billion dollar Center for Comparative Effectiveness Research, so that the federal government can compare various health care treatments. However, the bill contains no prohibitions on government-run health programs using such research to deny patients access to life-saving treatments, and a draft House Committee report earlier this year noted that such research funding meant that “more expensive [treatments] will no longer be prescribed.”
What this means for Americans: The billions in federal taxpayer dollars spent on comparative effectiveness research could be used by federal health programs to deny patients access to life-saving treatments.






